The wicked problem of socially responsible innovation.
نویسندگان
چکیده
O ne of the goals of our article on the DNA of Socially Responsible Innovation (SRI) was to start a discussion on how to implement SRI in research and development (R&D). We are therefore grateful for the contribution by Dove and Özdemir; we feel that exactly such dialogue is necessary to advance innovation to the next level. We acknowledge that the “ecosystem” of science, technology and society is much larger than the collaborative space between the natural scientist and the social sciences scholar that we describe in our article. Yet, our article portrays a starting point to “flesh out” SRI, making it tangible in innovation practice. Unfortunately, in discussions about SRI, perspectives for action are often omitted, which disconnects theoretical analyses on what SRI entails from “what I will do tomorrow in the laboratory.” At the core of SRI is an ill-defined “wicked problem.” The basis of this problem is that all levels of the innovation system— individual scientists, universities, industry, politics, society, and so on—generate emergent effects, which cannot be reduced to one single, most important element in the knowledge development system. As such, we feel that even the analysis and integration of political forces can only to a limited extent provide a concrete contribution. As such, we question whether political forces are at the heart of the issue, as Dove and Özdemir propose, given that policy aspects of sciences and technology often remain elusive to those who work on R&D. We would encourage exploring the value of adding a political narrator layer [1], but this assessment does not bring us closer to SRI, neither on practical nor on theoretical levels. By starting exactly at the heart of R&D, i.e. the laboratory, we could obtain system-level insights into how SRI-related effects are intertwined, which includes political effects. Still, system-level insights are futile if they do not provide practical starting points, or perhaps even and protocols for SRI. Entrenching ourselves in overly selfreflective socio-scientific debates about SRI could in fact paralyse the development of functional SRI procedures. In our opinion, collaborative spaces in which researchers from the natural and social sciences work together, can constitute such starting points. There is no indication that this “blunts” the social scientist’s critical and analytical role; rather, a collaborative space is a place where critical views are not only tolerated but also appreciated and taken seriously [2,3], since they help specify the “wickedness” of the SRI challenge. The epigenome is an interesting metaphor to further illustrate this wickedness. Still, the epigenomic view is reductionist in nature and may assert that SRI can at some point be “explained” by simply understanding the metaphorical “biological circumstances.” The question is whether one can realistically explain SRI in such a way, or whether it is more prudent to focus at certain parts of the system, which we have done in our research. As Dove and Özdemir highlight, this yields a more limited image of SRI, but at least a valuable and useful image, out of which further research on how to shape “effective” SRI can emerge bottom-up instead of top-down. Finally, the answer to Dove and Özdemir’s final question—does this (a more positive corporate image of science and technology) drive for keeping up appearances of socially responsible innovation really concern society—is “yes.” Institutes, research, scientists, industry, funding, politics, and so on are all part of society, with their own respective—positive or negative— impact on science and technology. One could even argue that keeping up appearances could be a good starting point for SRI, for appearances are the only way to illustrate SRI action to the outside world. We invite the authors and others to adopt the practical, trial-and-error approach, knowing that only practice makes perfect.
منابع مشابه
Nurturing Societal Values in and Through Health Innovations; Comment on “What Health System Challenges Should Responsible Innovation in Health Address?”
Aligning innovation processes in healthcare with health system demands is a societal objective, not always achieved. In line with earlier contributions, Lehoux et al outline priorities for research, public communication, and policy action to achieve this objective. We endorse setting these priorities, while also highlighting a ‘commitment gap’ in collectively addressing system-level challenges....
متن کاملResolving Wicked Problems In Information Systems Design
Wicked problems are subjective, interrelated and have no stopping rule. In a group that spans organizational boundaries, the resolution of wicked problems is especially problematic, as participants share minimal domain-knowledge. This paper discusses alternatives to current models of collaborative problem-solving, organizational innovation, and IS design, to understand how we may manage the pro...
متن کاملResolving Wicked Problems: Collaborative Information Systems Design in Boundary-Spanning Groups
Wicked problems are subjective, interrelated and have no stopping rule. In a group that spans organizational boundaries, the resolution of wicked problems is especially problematic, as participants share minimal domain-knowledge. This paper discusses alternatives to current models of collaborative problem-solving, organizational innovation, and IS design, to understand how we may manage the pro...
متن کاملFinancial Freedom and Socially Responsible Market Economy: An Analysis from Rawls’s Theory of Justice
Using Rawls's theory of justice, this paper addresses the empirical question of whether the socially responsible market economy can help explain the current situation in financial freedom, as well as its recent variation across countries. Utilizing annual data from selected countries of Middle East, North Africa, Asia and Oceania, and static panel estimation techniques, we provide evidence whic...
متن کاملBounding Wicked Problems: The C2 of Military Planning
Defining C2 as “the establishment of common intent to achieve coordinated action”, Pigeau and McCann outline a spectrum of approaches for coordinating action, ranging from explicit control through to spontaneous emergent behaviour. They further emphasise the role of creativity in Command. We examine application of Pigeau and McCann’s concepts of C2 to military planning in a headquarters. Many c...
متن کاملTaming wicked problems in modern health care systems.
IN ORDER TO BE MOST EFFECTIVE, health care systems need to be able to prioritize not just the provision of technologically advanced and potentially curative care but also the psychosocially advanced and compassionate palliative care. However, it is well known that modern health care systems are socially complex organizations often fraught with perverse incentives and internal conflicts that ser...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید
ثبت ناماگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید
ورودعنوان ژورنال:
- EMBO reports
دوره 15 5 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2014